Fuelishness! -- The FuelClinic.com Blog

“Cash for Clunkers” vs. “Cash for Un-Clunkers”

August 1, 2009 · · Filed Under Automotive Industry, FuelClinic, LinkedIn, Oil & Politics, Press Room, Twitter, United States 

[Updated: New link to “Cash for Un-Clunkers” added]

Far from a model of energy-efficiency, the CARS (Cash for Clunkers) program creates a system that encourages mind-boggling waste of energy, money, and natural resources.

The word “clunker” makes you think of cars with no real value left, in poor mechanical shape, incredibly inefficient, outdated, unsafe, and already a problem for the owner. The government program assumes the clunker is such a problem that the it requires that the “trade-ins” drive-train be destroyed within 2 days, else the dealer is fined $15,000. In reality, there are perfectly good vehicles with lots of value remaining – and can get measurably much better mileage if driven efficiently – being turned in and destroyed. 

Take for example this video of a decidedly “un-clunky” Volvo S40 or S80 being destroyed as part of the CARS program. All of the energy used to produce that car is completely wasted, even if it would still have value in the used car market.

WARNING: This is a surprisingly graphic video – especially if you are a “car guy”. This top-quality machine literally screams as the “liquid glass” solution (used in place of motor oil) scours the moving parts inside this engine, eventually overheating it enough to start a fire in the engine compartment, and puking it’s last remaining ounces of red-hot oil out onto the ground in front of it as it finally seizes up.

Some thoughts on this video:

  1. That’s a well engineered, safe, and fairly efficient high-quality car that apparently ran well when turned in.
  2. It has obvious value remaining (KBB says around $13K).
  3. I can’t believe it ran for over 4 minutes with sodium silicate instead of oil. 
  4. Thank goodness it didn’t puke up that red-hot oil all over the young man as he reached across the engine to put the oil fill cap (?) back on.  

On Wednesday it was announced that the program was suspended – some say it was because dealership couldn’t get their paperwork filed fast enough to not go bankrupt in the short-term, others said it was because the program was too successful and already “spent” all of it’s funding. Then yesterday it was announced that the program would be re-funded, using grants previously slated for other energy-efficiency improvement programs. 

I propose a different plan called: “Cash for Un-Clunkers

Can anyone answer me “why” we should scrap perfectly good cars instead of invest in improving driving habits?


4 Responses to ““Cash for Clunkers” vs. “Cash for Un-Clunkers””

  1. Announcing “Keep your Clunker – Keep your Cash” | Fuelishness! Fuel Economy Blog on August 2nd, 2009 8:55 AM

    […] out from a longer post […]

  2. Doc Miles on August 11th, 2009 1:02 PM

    From Email: Hello, Your recent coverage of Cash for Clunkers legislation on the Fuelishness blog (http://blog.fuelclinic.com/2009/08/01/some-thoughts-about-cash-for-clunkers/) was spot on. Many people will not qualify for the government program so I thought you might be interested in more info on vehicle donation alternatives to the Cash for Clunkers program. You could help charities a lot by adding a link to our informational page on Cash for Clunkers versus charitable car donation – http://www.donatecarusa.com/cashforclunkers. Charity Assistance Team Donate Car USA and for more than 400 charities – Toll-Free (888)-317-7279

  3. Announcing: IOU’s For Clunkers | Fuelishness! Fuel Economy Blog on August 19th, 2009 10:46 AM

    […] you’ve read this blog at all over the last month you know I do not support the CARS program because of it’s […]

  4. The Death of “Cash For Clunkers” | Fuelishness! Fuel Economy Blog on August 20th, 2009 10:49 PM

    […] like everyone has had enough of “Cash for Clunkers“: Through Thursday, auto dealers have made deals worth $1.9 billion and are on pace to […]

Leave a Reply

Join The FuelClinic Community

Fleet Eco-Driving Training

Spread the Fuelishness!


Watch Fuelishness!

Subscribe to Fuelishness!

Search Fuelishness!

Custom Search
FuelClinic.com - Safer, Smarter, Fuel Efficient Driving.